San Francisco Couple’s Anti-Pickleball Petition Clashes with Their Mansion’s Amenities

In a striking turn of events, Karl Peterson and his wife Holly, who spearheaded a petition against the noise from the Presidio Wall pickleball courts, are selling their Presidio Heights mansion that controversially includes its own pickleball court among its luxurious amenities. Listed for $29 million, down from an initial $36 million, the 12,000-square-foot home designed by Julia Morgan has become a focal point in San Francisco’s ongoing debate over urban noise and recreational space.

The Petersons’ campaign against the Presidio Wall courts drew significant attention last year when pickleball players and local residents learned of the private court tucked away in the couple’s mansion. The discovery prompted accusations of hypocrisy, especially as the public court's noise was noticeable yet reportedly contained. SF Parks and Recreation’s decision to convert some of the pickleball courts back to tennis courts seemed to appease some neighbors’ complaints but sparked further discourse on recreational rights versus residential peace.

The sale of the Petersons' mansion amid this backdrop highlights broader issues facing urban communities, such as balancing recreational needs with quality of life for nearby residents. The case also underscores the growing popularity of pickleball—a sport praised for its accessibility and social benefits but criticized for its noise. As cities like San Francisco continue to navigate these challenges, the story of the Petersons serves as a cautionary tale about community engagement and the complexities of urban living.